Home Review Review: Dark Legends, by George Mann

Review: Dark Legends, by George Mann

REVIEW OVERVIEW

Quality
Canon Compliance
Romance & Emotional Connections
Mythical Interest
In Character?

What the Force? Review Matrix

SUMMARY

Dark Legends, written by George Mann and illustrated by Grant Griffin, is a short collection of Star Wars stories based on well-trodden horror tales. The tales themselves fall flat and are not very scary, but they introduce variations on Star Wars concepts (the planetary effects of massive cracked kybers, the Jedi suppresion of the Dark Side...) and they are accompanied by fantastic illustrations.

Warning!!! This review contains spoilers for Dark Legends.

Dark Legends, written by George Mann and illustrated by Grant Griffin, is a short collection of Star Wars stories based on well-trodden horror tales. The seven legends are arranged in a loose chronological order (from a fan’s perspective – starting with The Clone Wars lore and finishing with a The Rise of Skywalker Exegol tale). Each legend is accompanied by an illustration, and the book is lovingly edited in the style of an Imperial Sith document.

George Mann is a good writer. For Dark Legends, he chose to follow the same XIX century moral tale imitation of Myths & Fables, his other Star Wars book, and he succeeds in reproducing that style. The mythical aspects of Star Wars are also present, particularly the fight between the light and the dark side of the Force, and Griffin’s illustrations by Grant Griffin are gorgeous and evocative.

However, the Dark Legends are not that original and not that scary… but they are extremely old fashioned in the worst sense. It’s unclear whether this was Mann’s intention, or if there was an editorial directive to keep it extremely PG and Hays Code compliant, but the result is a collection of musty, vaguely sexist and extremely moralistic tales that will put you to sleep.

For instance, The Orphanage is clearly based on Nosferatu and M: The Vampire of Dusseldorf: a mysterious figure –who turns out to be the Grand Inquisitor — keeps kidnapping Force-sensitive children from a Clone Wars orphanage until a plucky teenage girl asks for help through the Force. She doesn’t actually confront or kill him, acting only as the assistant of the Jedi that eventually answers her call.

Buyer Beware (where Galaxy’s Edge and Solo’s Dok Ondar collector makes a cameo!) is Star Wars version of The Mask; Blood Moon is a werewolf story, The Dark Mirror is Doctor Jekyll and Mr. Hyde the Jedi way and A Life Immortal revisits the Greek myths of Sibyl of Cumae and Tithonus, two people that tricked the gods into giving them eternal life but not eternal youth.

However, all of these stories have been used to one degree or another in different shows, films and books, and using well-known tropes reskinned for Star Wars would be perfectly good if they brought a new perspective to the trope… but they don’t. The heroic characters are sketches of archetypes, which makes it very difficult to empathize with them, and that’s terrible for horror stories. The one exception is Denholm, but then again… if you’ve seen any Star Wars you know that the poor guy is doomed from his first line, so why should you get invested?

The villain protagonists are so ridiculously evil that their bad endings feel like natural punishment (don’t dare to be ambitious, kids, or you’ll become corrupted, deformed and enslaved to your worst instincts). This also defeats the purpose of horror – horror is not supposed to ditch out justice and morally right endings, but to run a chill down your spine.

But what about sexism? Dark Legends has three tales with a female protagonist, three tales with a male protagonist and one tale where they share the spotlight. Every single one of the women is tricked by men – and that’s the source of their horror – and every man (except for Denholm, and again, poor guy) succumbs to his worst, most violent nature. It’s unclear why they picked these very specific twists, but after the fourth story they become frankly grating.

Now I’m addressing the lovers of monster romance in the audience: Dark Legends fights very hard against the idea of monster romance, particularly in The Orphanage, Blood Moon and The Gilded Cage. This book would like you to stop exploring that genre and go back to a time where women were pure of heart and free of sin, ambition and desire. The Gilded Cage is probably the most offensive of the bunch.

That said, Dark Legends works some pretty interesting Star Wars ideas into its myths. For instance, the lycanthropy in Blood Moon is caused by the solar flares emitted by a star with a core of cracked kyber, the macro version of the bleeding kyber crystals that power Sith lightsabers, which are inextricably linked to their wielder’s emotional state. Imagine an entire planet bathed on that kind of pain and you have an apt Homus Homine Lupus in the Galaxy far, far away.

The Dark Mirror could also be read as a call-out to the Jedi obsession with incorruptible pure goodness, and their eons-long quest to suppress their shadows instead of understanding and assimilating them.

“In recognizing the true horror of both his and his master’s failure and the terrible acts they had committed, Sol Mogra knew he could never face his Jedi masters, for the shame had already begun to consume him and would burn him up from inside, twisting him into a thing of hate.”

A Life Immortal, which follows a Sith Lady in her quest for eternal life in Exegol has a tongue-in-cheek connection to none other than Pickled Snoke from The Rise of Skywalker. As mentioned above, this legend seems to be based on the Sibyl of Cumae myth of eternal without eternal youth, and in Ovid’s The Metamorphoses, Sibyl’s body grew smaller with age until she could be kept in a jar… just like the protagonist remains in Exegol forever, shriveled and deformed (and maybe, after Palps arrived, in her own jar?).

The illustrations are also beautiful and very intriguing. Grant Griffin decided to paint the Grand Inquisitor from The Orphanage in a ’20s vampire style, claws and fangs included, and his vision of the Darth Lady of Exegol with a deformed assistant, Force lightning, a curved lightsaber, and that petrified lotus-like throne is wonderful and very reminiscent of Frankenstein imagery. Griffin’s strokes are very expressive, and his style is perfect for the genre.

So, should you buy Dark Legends? It depends. If you are looking for the ultimate collection of Star Wars horror stories, this is not it – but, to be fair, that collection might never exist. However, if you are a collector of beautiful objects, the book’s edition is exquisite – the font is beautiful, the subtle Sith and Imperial themed filigrees are very smart and the art is great.

Bea Caicoya
Bea Caicoyahttps://www.cbr.com/author/bcai/
Bea is a Euro transplant currently living in Toronto. She enjoys sinking her teeth in massive transmedia franchises and stress-testing them to find holes in the matrix... that will hopefully lead to a World between Worlds. You can endure her shameless self-promotion by joining her handful of Twitter followers at @BeaCaicoya, or read more of her nonsense at CBR.

2 COMMENTS

  1. “vaguely sexist and extremely moralistic tales” is a very interesting thought… to be honest, that sums up what has made me back off the Disney Era of Star Wars and what I see as the main creative problem for the franchise going forward. I just hope the inevitable changes in creators will allow Star Wars stories to breathe… to connect to our human experiences, not just preach to us from a soap box of righteousness.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Most Popular

Was Mandalore the Scottish Highlands of a Galaxy Far, Far Away?

One the events of Mandalore’s recent, painful past, The Great Purge, where the Empire killed and exiled many Mandalorians and took all of their Beskar, bears a resemblance to Scottish history and its turbulent relation with British rulers -- specifically, to the Battle of Culloden of 1746, the swansong of the ancestral Scottish clan structure.

Power of Myth & Symbolism: Violence in The Mandalorian

Join our host Marie-Claire Gould (@mariecgould) and co-host Ty Black (@black_Tym and Wit & Folly on YouTube) in our Segment the Power...

Tale of the Nine-Tailed Deep Dive Chapters 5 & 6

What the Fiction will be covering Tale of the Nine-Tailed Covering Tale of the Nine-Tailed K Drama: A modern telling of the...

Holonet Dispatch SPECIAL EDITION: Where Are the Stars of the Sequel Trilogy Now?

Hello everyone! We interrupt our regularly scheduled programming to bring you a Very Special Edition of Holonet Dispatch. We love to see...

Recent Comments

Marie-Claire Gould on Review: Dark Legends, by George Mann
What The Force on Interview with Charles Soule
Vagabond Debris on Interview with Charles Soule
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!